11/12/2025
A little bit of a warning for those that throttle their IRA distributions based on tax brackets and deductions. I just received a preliminary software for tax season. It is very early, so planning for some is probably not ready yet. However, I have already had discussions with over 65 clients regarding IRA withdraw, here is an example:
2024 - Lets take a Single filer over 65, in 2024 they want zero tax but want to maximize deductions so as not to leave any unused deductions. In 2024 they had $20,000 of SS Income and took $16,000 out of their IRA. Under 2024 tax law, their total income for tax purposes was $16,000 IRA and a taxable portion of SS Income of $500. Since the Standard Deduction was $16,500 in 2024, they have used every dollar of deduction and paid zero tax.
2025 - Same client wants to accomplish same thing again and knows there is a new $6,000 senior deduction and their standard deduction went up by $1,250. So they immediately think they can take $7,250 more out of their IRA. At tax time this is how the numbers would play out. SS Income is now $20,500 with COLA increase, IRA withdraw bumped to $23,200 ($16,000 plus the new $6,000 deduction and $1,250 increase in standard deduction). The tax return would now have $23,200 IRA plus $4,225 of taxable SS Income. The more the IRA goes up the more taxable SS goes on the return. Gross income is $27,425 and deductions are $23,750 (Std Deduction of $17,750 and senior deduction of $6,000). They have $3,675 of taxable income and $368 of tax due while expecting zero.
While not the end of the world, it did not meet the objective of zero tax due to the fact that increasing IRA distribution also increased the taxable portion of SS Income. It gets worse on a married filing joint return and also for those that might be trying to fill the 10% bracket.
There are never simple answers when it comes to tax law and don't try to apply logic to an illogical system. Planning is your only answer. Until working through the problem, you really won't know the answer.