05/06/2026
**You set up an LLC five years ago because someone told you that's what business owners do.**
And every year since, your CPA has filed a Schedule C, you've paid self-employment tax on everything, and you assumed that's just how it works.
Nobody ever mentioned there might be a different way once the business actually started making money.
I see this constantly with business owners netting $200K, $300K, even $500K. Still running the same LLC structure from when they were doing $60K in revenue.
Not because they love paying extra taxes. Because nobody told them when to revisit it.
There are three moments when it's worth asking that question:
**Your profit crossed $80,000 and kept climbing**
A business netting $350,000 as a standard LLC pays self-employment tax on the full amount. That's 15.3% before income tax even starts.
Quick math: 15.3% of $350,000 is about $53,500 just in payroll taxes.
Same business with an S-Corp election: You pay yourself a $140,000 salary. The other $210,000 comes out as distributions with no payroll tax.
Savings? Around $32,000 per year. Subtract $2,500 for payroll processing and you're still pocketing nearly $30,000 annually.
At $80,000 in profit, the math is marginal. At $250,000? You're funding someone else's tax bill for no reason.
**You maxed your SEP and realized it's not enough**
If you're trying to shelter $150,000 or $200,000 per year, a SEP won't get you there.
S-Corp owners can run a Solo 401(k) with profit sharing. Or stack a cash balance plan on top.
But you need W-2 wages to unlock those plans. LLC owners taxed as sole proprietors don't have W-2 wages.
Your entity choice is directly capping how much you can defer.
**Your income stabilized and you can explain what you do**
S-Corps require reasonable compensation. If your income swings wildly or your role is impossible to define, documenting a defensible salary becomes a nightmare.
But if your business throws off consistent profit and you can clearly describe what you do, the S-Corp structure is straightforward to justify.
**Where this falls apart:**
Business owners elect S-Corp status, set up payroll, then forget about it.
Three years later the business has doubled. But the salary they set when they first elected? Still the same.
Now they're either leaving retirement contributions on the table or risking an IRS conversation about reasonable comp.
If your LLC is netting over $100K and nobody has asked whether an S-Corp makes sense, you're probably operating with a structure designed for a business half your size.