01/22/2021
What is BETTER? ROTH IRA, Traditional IRA or Regular Investment savings?
The answer is it depends on your specific situation. However, let us take a look at the type of money you want at retirement. I think most would say TAX FREE MONEY is the best. Well, the ROTH IRA is tax free when you distribute after 59 1/2. However, you do not get a current write-off when contributing.
The Traditional IRA gives you a current write-off and the earnings on the account are not taxed until withdrawn. In other words, you will earn income on the money you would have otherwise paid taxes on. Unfortunately, the downside is the distribution is taxable at regular tax rates when withdrawn and at 72 you have required minimum distributions. This is fine if you are in a high tax bracket now and expect to be in a lower tax bracket when you retire.
Lastly is Regular Investment Savings. Here you do not get any current tax benefit. All income earned is taxed immediately unlike the ROTH which is never taxed and unlike the Traditional IRA which is taxed at distribution. However, if you are investing in stocks or mutual funds that you hold for at least a year, you get taxed at long term capital gain rates which are lower than the ordinary rates at retirement.
Bottom line ... for my money, in most cases, the ROTH IRA is the best vehicle if you qualify. The investment and income are never taxed and there are no mandatory distributions at 72.
As mentioned earlier, it really depends upon your specific situation. Before deciding, you should consult with your tax specialist and financial advisor.